Moscow
18 November 2026 / 02:08
Moscow
18 November 2026 / 02:08
Котировки
USD
18/11
currency
82.4529
0.0000
EUR
18/11
currency
90.8136
0.0000
Economy

Nvidia spy scandal: "out the door, back in through the window"

The timing looks deliberately set against the US-China summit in Shenzhen

Nvidia spy scandal: "out the door, back in through the window" Nvidia spy scandal: "out the door, back in through the window"

Shenzhen is getting ready to host the leaders of the Asia-Pacific region (APEC). For China, the summit will become the centerpiece of its APEC chairmanship, taking stock of work on three priorities: openness, innovation, and cooperation. The People’s Republic intends to use the meeting to discuss how participants can expand trade, take up new technologies, and lower barriers to business.

Shenzhen is getting ready to host the leaders of the Asia-Pacific region (APEC). For China, the summit will become the centerpiece of its APEC chairmanship, taking stock of work on three priorities: openness, innovation, and cooperation. The People’s Republic intends to use the meeting to discuss how participants can expand trade, take up new technologies, and lower barriers to business.

By all appearances, the United States has different priorities now. For years China and the US have been rivals across industry after industry, above all in high technology — microchips, electric vehicles, equipment for "green" energy. But recent years have brought something new. American technological superiority, once beyond question, now has to be defended amid China's rapidly growing influence. And the methods both sides use in this contest can hardly be called market ones. Governments impose discriminatory tariffs and preferences, meddle in business, and tear up trade chains. The result is not only slower growth at home but higher global inflation and damage to resource suppliers around the globe.

As The Economist observed, another feature of this stage — and one that sets it apart from the 2018-2019 trade war — is that both sides are better prepared and are using not just tariffs but export controls, sanctions, and regulatory pressure. Full-scale escalation has so far been avoided; indeed, until recently tensions had been easing. At their September meeting in Washington, presidents Xi Jinping and Donald Trump agreed a package of mutual tariff cuts on goods worth $60 billion, including some $17 billion of US farm produce. Those purchases came on top of the pledge to buy American soybeans made last October.

The plan, though, has yet to be finalized: China wants to keep working on more favorable trade conditions — a joint tariff cut, fewer non-tariff barriers, wider market access. That is probably why Beijing is not in a hurry as regards the implementation. Reuters reports that from January to September China bought just $7.2 billion of US agricultural produce, meat and corn included — the lowest since 2019. The slow procurement pace has deepened doubts that imports will rise sharply this year, piling pressure on American farmers already faced with high fuel costs. China, for its part, is waiting for firmer agreements on tariff cuts.

Against that backdrop, the scandal around Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang poured fuel on the fire — and could give Washington a pretext for fresh IT restrictions in the name of national security. Notably, the US had already restricted supplies of Nvidia's most powerful processors to Chinese buyers, fearing military and strategic use. Huang has repeatedly urged to ease restrictions, arguing that the bans stop American and Chinese firms from competing with each other. Any attempt to reach Nvidia's secrets through Huang therefore matters not only because of his job but because he played a prominent part in shaping Washington's debate on AI exports. So, the accusations against Huang have become one more argument in a campaign Chinese experts have already dubbed a "witch hunt." China has urged the US to stop inventing "Chinese spy" stories and using them as a pretext for technology restrictions. As Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Mao Ning put it, "as for the so-called 'Chinese spies,' we have already made our position clear. China's scientific and technological progress rests on independent innovation and open cooperation." She added that the two sides remain in close contact on high-level exchanges and that China is ready to work with the US to implement the important agreements reached by their two presidents.

In the US, though, the fallout has already reached well beyond Nvidia. American legislators intend to use the affair to push through a whole battery of measures aimed at China's semiconductor industry: mandatory chip tracking, tighter congressional control over chip export licenses, and agreement with US allies on curbing exports to China of chipmaking equipment. Reuters reported on November 9 that three legislative initiatives could be folded into the US National Defense Act for fiscal 2027 — the Chip Security Act, which would companies to track the chips they supply to prevent smuggling; an AI control bill; and the MATCH Act, on multilateral coordination of hardware technology restrictions, designed to push US allies into tightening curbs on exports to China of chipmaking equipment. Republican Senator Jim Banks noted that the scandal would help move them along. Earlier US restrictions on semiconductor exports to China, I would note, were mainly imposed by the Commerce Department under its administrative powers, through amendments to the Export Administration Regulations and the relevant control lists. Writing additional restrictions directly into legislation, however, would make them considerably harder to undo later. 

China's reaction was not long in coming. As Shen Yi, director of the Institute of International Studies in Global Cyberspace Governance at Fudan University, put it, "this scandal has to be seen against the background of an increasingly hostile attitude toward China in Washington. Under the cover of national security, Washington is steadily widening the scope of restrictions. And if the legislative requirements for mandatory chip-tracking mechanisms and expanded supervisory powers are adopted and implemented, Chinese companies may quite reasonably doubt that Nvidia chips are free of tracking functions or tools for bypassing the protection system. Concerns about data security may in the end prompt Chinese enterprises to abandon the company's products."

So, a breakthrough at the Shenzhen meeting between Xi Jinping and Donald Trump is hard to expect. The Chinese and American leaders may well try to focus on dialogue, but they will be pursuing different goals — despite all the temporary truces and high-level talks, the contradictions are here to stay.

  • new_top